Rutherford County School Board VS Rutherford County Commission

School Board and County Commission Can't Agree on Who Should Control School Design and Construction

Please refresh as we try to update daily.

November 22, 2000: The costs are starting to come in. School building argument cost $69K: Board sued county to keep authority over construction By Scott Broden, DNJ Staff writer and County Commission put lawsuit down softly By Bryan Brooks, DNJ Staff writer.

November 16, 2000: It is all over! Tax break for company considered: County leaders will also vote on lawsuit with school board By Bryan Brooks, DNJ Staff writer. They voted 20-0 to not appeal.

October 20, 2000: County School Board wins the appeal of their lawsuit against the County Commission!

Court of Appeals Opinions - 4th Quarter 2000

"Rutherford Co. Bd. of Ed. vs. Rutherford Co. Comm. - M1999-00288-COA-R3-CV

This is a declaratory judgment action on undisputed facts. The question for disposition is whether the Public Building Authorities Act of 1971 authorizes the Rutherford County Commission to direct the Rutherford County Public Buildings Authority to hire architects, select a contractor and prepare school building design plans for presentation to the Rutherford County School Board. The trial court held that it is the responsibility of the Rutherford County Board of Education to plan, locate, erect and furnish public schools in Rutherford County and that the Rutherford County Commission was without authority to direct the Rutherford County Public Buildings Authority to act in this respect. We affirm the trial court."
The web-site's PDF file of the opinion contains a great narrative on the 'turf war'. Need a PDF reader?

Dateline October 22, 2000: DNJ High court rules in school board suit: Appeals court gives building authority to board By Jim Mahanes, DNJ News editor.

Dateline October 29, 2000: DNJ Decison made on school building, move ahead a DNJ Opinion Column

The 1967 Private Act

Chapter 454, Section 10

SECTION 10. That the County School Board shall have the responsibility for the government, supervision, and control of the public schools of the County, provided, however that no Board member shall have authority to act independently on any school matter. The Board shall generally exercise all powers, duties, and privileges as set forth in the public laws of Tennessee relative to County Boards of Education and specifically discharge those duties enumerated in Section 49-214 and Section 49-215, Tennessee Code Annotated, which are not in conflict with the provisions of this Act.

It shall be the duty of the County Board of Education to elect, from nominations or recommendations made by the Superintendent of Schools, but not otherwise, all principals, teachers, and other employees of the County School System: and to fix the salaries of principals, teachers, and other employees of the County School System, within the funds available or provided by the Quarterly County Court.

It shall be the duty of the Board to plan for the extension and development of the County School System; to determine the need for new buildings; to plan, locate, erect, and furnish the same, after the Quarterly County Court shall have provided funds for same.

The Board shall adopt written policies and regulations for the proper functioning of the Board and the School System. It shall have drawn up and made available for general distribution a statement of such policies and regulations.

The Board shall assign to the County Superintendent of Schools such duties as are set forth in Section 49-224, Tennessee Code Annotated, and any other such duties as can reasonable be expected of the superintendent.


Latest news on the issue

Dateline May 6, 2000:

Senate kills county’s PBA legislation: Bill would have given power to negotiate contracts By Scott Broden, DNJ Staff writer.
Dateline April 9, 2000: Cost of building schools to skyrocket: Quality construction, higher wages add up I guess Blackman High School's $79.50 a square foot looks pretty good now.
Dateline April 1, 2000: County’s PBA bill may violate Tennessee law: Legal Services says private act conflicts with existing legislation By Jim Mahanes, DNJ Staff writer. Ya think?
Dateline April 14, 2000: Commission says hold up on Blackman: Farley asks for money without committee OK By Jim Mahanes, DNJ Editor/writer. Commissioner Farley had the audacity to ask that another school get started. Way to go Gary! Nice Try!
Dateline March 22, 2000: Board asserts authority to build schools with resolution By Scott Broden, DNJ Staff writer and Blackman Middle School funding votes fall short By Jim Mahanes, DNJ Staff writer.
Dateline March 20, 2000: IT’S ALL OR NOTHING ON TAX PACKAGE: County residents must choose how to pay for growing needs By Jim Mahanes, DNJ Staff writer.
Dateline March 19, 2000: Commission seeks building oversight: Vote asks change in law on school board By Jim Mahanes, DNJ Staff writer.
Blackman’s beauty no reason for county to cry foul a DNJ Opinion Column.
Blackman Taj Mahal is just a myth by Mike Pirtle, DNJ Staff Columnist.
‘Our own little trailer park’: Principals project need for 45 more portable classes foreseen By Scott Broden, DNJ Staff writer

Dateline March 10, 2000:

Superintendent defends design, cost of new Blackman High: Couynty Commissioners called it ‘Taj Mahal’ of education By Byron Hensley, DNJ Staff writer.
Dateline March 9, 2000: Commissioners call Blackman ‘extravagant’: Steering panel wants PBA in on school design
Dateline January 31, 2000: School building argument set: County appeal in court today By Jim Mahanes, DNJ Staff writer.

Enrollment and Portables in the county

Local Spending on Local Schools

By the way, Rutherford County Schools meets or exceeds the national average of educational quality at almost every turn.

Historical Events

Fifteen county commissioners had a letter-to-the-editor printed July 4, 1999 in the DNJ, Commission committed to education but the numbers seem to be in question, and a local resident has a web-site questioning their numbers, http://members.home.net/andfowler/budget/ and I think he is still looking for answers?